You are comparing two recruiter proposals. One quotes 22 percent of the first-year salary. The other is SuperHired’s $7,500 standard search. The fee difference is easy to calculate. Comparing what the proposals include takes a closer look.
Start with the price, then read the scope, payment terms, deliverables and replacement-search conditions. Those are commitments you can check before choosing a recruiter.
How percentage and flat fees work
A percentage fee changes with the salary or compensation figure defined in the agreement. Check which pay components the quote includes and what triggers payment.
A flat fee sets the search price in advance. It can still include a payment due on an accepted offer, as ours does. The price format alone does not tell you how much discovery, sourcing or assessment a recruiter will do.
Ask for the work to be set out. Who will lead the search? What will they learn about the role? How will they approach candidates, assess evidence and report concerns? What happens if the role changes?

A recruiting business has costs beyond any single placement. Its fee does not reveal how those costs are allocated or how many hours it will spend on your search. The proposal should explain the service you are buying.
If the hire does not work out
The initial fee is only one part of the decision. If a hire does not work out, you may also face a vacancy, another search, onboarding work and time away from other priorities.
Estimate those costs from your own situation. Keep any new recruiting fee separate from internal costs, and check that the same cost has not been counted twice. A broad replacement-cost estimate is not a reliable total for your particular hire.
Then read each recruiter’s replacement terms. Check the period covered, the circumstances that qualify, what you must do and what the recruiter will provide. Do not assume that either a percentage fee or a flat fee includes the same protection.
SuperHired includes a 120-day replacement-search guarantee under the agreed service terms. We explain those conditions before you commit. It is a commitment about the replacement search, not a forecast of how long a hire will stay.
Compare the work included
A lower fee is useful when the service meets your needs. To assess that, compare the work each proposal commits to doing.
Look for a clear role definition, a search plan, job-related assessment and a written account of the evidence behind each recommendation. Ask how much of your time is needed and which decisions remain yours.
At SuperHired, discovery comes before headhunting. We agree the role, pay, search plan and selection steps in the Hiring Blueprint. Candidate conversations and, where useful, a paid Work Simulation then address the questions that matter for that role.
That is the process to compare with another proposal. A fee label cannot tell you how thorough or candid an individual recruiter will be.
Two fee examples
These examples use a hypothetical 22 percent fee and assume the role is agreed as a SuperHired standard search at $7,500. The percentage is an illustration, not an industry average or a quote from another supplier. The comparison covers recruiting fees only.
Scenario 1: Hiring a media buyer at $85,000.
A 22 percent fee is $18,700. Against a $7,500 standard search, the fee difference is $11,200.
Before choosing, compare the proposed discovery, candidate assessment, deliverables and replacement terms. The arithmetic does not establish which service will produce the stronger hire.
Scenario 2: Hiring an account manager at $120,000.
A 22 percent fee is $26,400. Against a $7,500 standard search, the fee difference is $18,900.
For this role, discovery might examine how the person will balance client relationships, delivery and margins. Relevant examples, structured questions and a role-specific exercise can give you evidence to discuss. Confirm that the proposal includes the assessment your role needs.
Our standard fee stays the same when the salary changes. Specialist or technical searches cost $10,000 to $15,000, and executive searches cost $15,000 to $25,000. We agree the role’s fee before starting. Use that agreed fee and the other recruiter’s actual quote for your own comparison.
What you keep
Our deliverables are yours to keep, whatever the outcome. Four examples show how the work can support a later search or a discussion with your team.
The Right Person Profile records the role’s demands, the work environment and the evidence to look for when assessing candidates. If you hire internally or use a different recruiter next time, it gives that search a shared starting point.
The Work Environment Scan records how your company operates: how decisions get made, how fast the work moves and how much autonomy the role provides. It gives you working conditions to discuss with candidates and revisit for future searches.
The Job Map is a candidate-facing document that shows the work, the environment and the expectations. It helps candidates decide whether they want to explore the role and gives both sides a clear basis for questions.
The Salary Benchmark checks the role’s pay range against the market. Revisit it when the role, location or market changes.
Ask each recruiter to show you examples of their deliverables and confirm what you can keep and reuse.
For more on the work involved, read what recruiting agencies do and what they skip.
Compare the written scope, the payment terms and the deliverables alongside the fee.
Compare the replacement-search terms
Our 120-day replacement-search guarantee is subject to the agreed service terms. Review those conditions alongside the rest of the proposal, including the event that starts the period and the steps required if a problem arises.
A useful comparison asks what support each recruiter provides after the start, which circumstances qualify for a replacement search and whether any further charges apply. Those answers come from the agreement, not the fee model.
Discovery and job-related assessment are intended to make the role, evidence and unresolved questions clear before an offer. A guarantee provides a defined response if an eligible placement does not work out. They serve different purposes.
Check what you are paying for
What are you paying for, when is it due, and what will you have when the work is done?
For a SuperHired search, 30 percent is due at signing and 70 percent when an offer is accepted. The agreed fee does not rise with the salary. You approve the role, pay, shortlist and offer. We handle the work between those decisions.
Ask any recruiter how they will surface concerns, document their reasoning and keep you informed. Evaluate those commitments and the person who will carry them out.
If you want to start evaluating candidates differently today, here are 12 questions to use in your next interview.
Our discovery process takes about three hours of structured time with SuperHired, plus your finalist interviews and decision time. A standard search is $7,500, with a 120-day replacement-search guarantee under the agreed service terms.


